Black Maple HIll Small Batch Bourbon Review

Black Maple Hill Small Batch 47.5% ABV/ 95 Proof $40

Black Maple Hill Small Batch 47.5% ABV/ 95 Proof

Info in this post does not apply to the latest Oregon whiskies from BMH

Black Maple Hill (47.5 ABV, 95 Proof/$40) Of all of the non-distiller producers (NDP) out there, Black Maple Hill is easily the most sought after. It is one of the older NDPs still putting out bottles, and the early stuff was legendary. Now, the orange labeled no-age statement Black Maple Hill is all that remains and the details are fuzzy. While demand may be high, clarity is very, very low.

K&L article by Dave Driscoll gives the most detailed background on BMH on the web, citing who owns BMH and even names Willett as the organization charged with blending the juice, but the provenance of the actual bourbon is still unknown. We know it comes from Kentucky, and there are rumors that it is Heaven Hill stock, but no one really knows. All I can say for Black Maple Hill and the rest of the NDPs is if they can prove to produce a consistent product that people enjoy at a reasonable price, the NDP background won’t be such a problem.

Black Maple Hill

Most of the hype for Black Maple Hill started in the early 2000’s. The Lawrenceburg Black Maple Hills were bottled by a Mr. Van Winkle, King Midas himself. Right now, a used napkin of Julian Van Winkle’s second nephew would sell on eBay, so any bottle with a Van Winkle link is instantly vaulted to the highest regard for collectors and flippers. The previous 14 through 20 year age stated Black Maple Hill bourbons, as well as the legendary high age ryes have created lightening in a bottle for the standard 8-ish year, orange labeled (black wax), standard Black Maple Hill. Even the recent $150 Black Maple Hill 16 year has quite a bit of fanfare, but it is important to know what you are looking at next time you see BMH on a shelf.

Black Maple Hill 16 Year, same bottle, black ink. BMH16 came out as a small batch as well as a single barrel.

Black Maple Hill 16 Year, same bottle, black ink. BMH16 came out as a small batch as well as a single barrel.

Since BMH is equally as absent as the BTAC, Parker’s Heritage, and Four Roses LE from your liquor store shelf, the assumption can be made that BMH is equally as good as said brands. The problem is, rare availability does not always equal rare quality.

NDPs are usually pretty low on the food chain when it comes to barrel availability. Undesignated barrels of bourbon are becoming harder and harder for NDPs to obtain as the boom goes on. Releases like Eagle Rare 17 and the Parker’s Heritage are limited because only a few barrels reach the quality needed to obtain the brand’s desired profile. That is rare quality. Black Maple Hill is at the will of whomever distills the barrels they use. Since BMH is just another face in a long line of NDPs, their brand is rare because they don’t have access to tons of barrels, and they do not control production. That is rare availability.

With that said, Black Maple Hill’s sourced bourbon can still be worth the hype, but until you can decide that for yourself, know that BMH is not worth some of the extreme, demand driven mark-up that is out there. Aside from the limited availability, there is nothing special about the orange labeled, “Limited Edition” Black Maple Hill. As you read in the K&L article, the Van Winkle provenance is long gone. The age is average at best, and you have no idea what it will taste like from batch to batch because there is no way to know whose barrels CVI Brands will have access to when the next batch come around.

For $39.99, you are getting a good value for the price, but don’t let a lone bottle of BMH placed on the top shelf of your liquor store pressure you in to paying anywhere north of $60.

But, if it is a rye or an age stated L’burg bourbon, bye that sucker no matter the price!

Nose: There is a lot of corn upfront, and as the bottle opens up, that corny, young nose fades quite a bit. Lots of honey and oak start to show up in the nose, with some sharp spice. Cinnamon pie and snickerdoodle cookies come to mind.

Sip: Good texture, with a quick sweetness showing up in the front. Caramelized sugar, thick warm honey, candied pecans and lots more of that sweet corn. There is some nice rye spice, like a spicy baking cinnamon, some cloves and a nutty back end. Some oaky vanilla notes finish the sip in the  back palate.

Finish: The finish is decent. Not too long, not short but not very complex either. Classic bourbon tastes are there, but the most prominent tastes to me are the sweetness and the corn, with the spice and oak a distant second.

In the glass, BMH gets a little more complex with a couple minutes. That upfront sweetness hides and you get more of the oak and rye spice that really complements the remaining corn and sweet tones of the bourbon.

Overall Grade: B

Black Maple Hill Small Batch is a solid pour of bourbon. The nose is awake, and there is plenty to pick apart in the profile for the price, but it is shy of what I would call a “refined” bourbon. The nutty, oak spice, as well as the baking spices from the rye are pretty sharp, which makes the sweet notes and the young corn flavor a bit unbalanced. For the price, BMH is a good value, but I certainly wouldn’t pay beyond $40 for the bottle.

Drink this, not that: Black Maple Hill Small Batch does just fine in its category. It is in the upper echelon of the $40 and under category (I got mine with some “points” so BMH might be low $40’s where you are). I like it better than Maker’s 46, Eagle Rare, Woodford Reserve and Jefferson’s Small Batch and Reserve Bourbon, but Elmer T. Lee ($10 cheaper than BMH), Old Rip Van Winkle 107 Proof ($37), most Four Roses Single Barrels ($32-$50) and Elijah Craig 12 Year (low $30’s) are better buys in my opinion.

If you run across a bottle marked up to $50, $70, or even $100, I would skip it Up in that price range, you can get a bottle of EH Taylor Single Barrel, which is a far superior bourbon with a much more consistent source. EH Taylor is what I would call a refined single barrel, which comes with a lot of the balance and depth that I find missing in the small batch BMH.

18 responses to “Black Maple HIll Small Batch Bourbon Review

  1. Great review – honest and insightful. I discovered Black Maple Hill a couple years ago, and have seen the “buzz” rise and impact availability. BMH is a truly quality bourbon, though its story is certainly equal to its taste. For a while, the only place I found it in Colorado was up in Vail – and the guys at Alpine Wine and Spirits know their bourbon. For more on the story of BMH, you might check out this review:


  2. Thanks for the comment and thanks for reading. That’s good stuff on that K&L post! I’ll throw that link up top so people can see that at least the people handling the whiskey are whiskey people.

    The large box stores here in Colorado never have it (except Argonaut) but the small guys in the know stock it. I am up in Vail next month for the Tough Mudder, I will make sure to stop by Alpine Wine and Spirits.


  3. Greetings from the great Commonwealth of Kentucky. Enjoyed your post and love BMH. I own about 50 bourbons and put it in the top 15


    • Though Willett is referred to as a distillery, they don’t actually distill whiskey right now. They did back in the day. Right now, they buy whiskey from other companies, most often Heaven Hill, and then sell it under their brands label.

      What it seems Willett does for BMH is buy whiskey from someone, blend it to taste, and then bottle it for that guy in California to sell as BMH.


      • I was just at Willett last week and they are distilling and when another person on the tour asked about BMH, they did say they distill it. (But obviously don’t sell it there.) It also looks like they are now a fully functioning distillery from what I saw of the operation. It is truly a gem to visit. One of the prettiest distilleries in Kentucky and they are putting in a B&B on site which is definitely something to look forward to in the next few years.


      • Thanks Jennifer, that is great info, and a B&B at a distillery is just brilliant. I love the idea of Willett adding Black Maple Hill to their KBD brands. Loosing the scarlet letter of being an NDP will be huge for Black Maple Hill once those Willett barrels mature. If I recall correctly, they are at their third year right now, so they could be putting out their own Family Estate bottles very soon. I know a lot of people including myself are very anxious to see how their four year rye comes out!


  4. I’m here CO and am having a hard time find BHM. I always bought one for my B-day and spring break fishing trip.


  5. I bought it for 42. Glad I did. Wouldn’t have been happy till I tried it myself. Good stuff. Although it needed a couple days after opening to become good stuff. Looks like a local has it for $49. I don’t think it was good enough for that price. If I can find it for about $40 I MIGHT buy it again.


    • My thoughts exactly. When I find it for $39, I am tempted, but when I see it for $50, $75, and $110, I laugh. There are worse things to be stuck drinking, but for $50, there are just too many great options.


  6. Great post. I used to be checking constantly this blog
    and I’m impressed! Extremely helpful info particularly the final
    section 🙂 I care for such information much. I was looking for
    this particular info for a very lengthy time. Thank you and best of luck.


  7. Maybe my palette isn’t as sophisticated, but I’ve had some of the ones that rank high (including ORVW 10), and BMH is my absolute favorite bourbon on Earth. I was genuinely depressed when they discontinued the Kentucky line and started the inferior Oregon batch. Here in Massachusetts, it was usually available for 40-50 and I bought when I could find them. Love your site by the way, I’ve been lurking here a while and it’s because of you I found Stranahan’s, so thanks for that.


  8. I have done a lot of research on BMH, mosty because I desperately want a particular vintage. There a great many people swept up in the cult of this brand, driven by a love of the chase and the chance to acquire something others can’t get. That’s not me.
    Dining in my favorite restaurant in the world, in Savannah, GA around 2005-06, I asked for by standard top shelf bourbon, which they were out of. The waitress suggested I try a “new, small batch called Black Maple Hill” they just got in, and that customers seemed to love. She brought they bottle for me to see. It was absolutely fantastic. In fact, it may have been the best bourbon I’ve ever had.
    I immediately came home to Tampa Bay and tracked down three bottles. As I said, this was years ago. I thought it was 10 year old, but the old, blue-text labels I have been able to find online is 11-year old whiskey.
    I understand that the presently available BMH varies greatly, depending n age with some getting truly awful reviews, and others coming in between average and pretty good.
    I am only interested in what I believe to be the original 10 or 11 year old bourbon. I know this would be a fairly old bottle and difficult to find. If anyone has a line on this, any info would be GREATLY appreciated!


    • I’ve never heard of that expression. I know the L’burg 15 year with the grey label but the blue is new to me. Sounds rare, sounds expensive, so I wish you the best of luck. Going to be a hard hunt.


  9. I recently obtained a bottle of black maple hill 18 year rye. It’s barrel number is r70. I have no idea if this was a bottle that van winkle had anything to do with or if it was a bottle that KBD bottled. Do you know how to find this out, and how to date this bottle?


What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s